Raise, Renovate, or Rebuild? How to Decide What to Do With a Coastal Home in Connecticut
Suggested meta description: Own an older home near Long Island Sound? Here's how flood zones, the FEMA 50% rule and Connecticut's building
code shape the choice between renovating, raising and rebuilding.

If you own an older house near Long Island Sound, the question eventually comes up: do we fix it, lift it, or start over?
It usually shows up at a bad moment. A storm leaves water in the basement. An insurance renewal comes in higher than last year. A buyer's inspector starts asking about the flood zone. Or you simply want a bigger kitchen and a second-floor primary suite, and the building department tells you the project is bigger than you thought.
We get this question every week at Faros Design. Here's how we help homeowners think it through, and why our answer is sometimes different from what you'll hear elsewhere.
Start with two facts: your flood zone and the 50% rule
Before anyone talks about design, you need to know where your house sits on FEMA's flood map and how its current floor height compares with the base flood elevation (BFE), the level floodwater is expected to reach in a major storm.
On the Connecticut shoreline you'll mostly see three designations:
AE zones, where flooding is expected but waves are smaller.
Coastal A zones, closer to the water, where moderate waves add force.
VE zones, right on the coast, where storm waves hit with real energy.
The second fact is what FEMA calls substantial improvement, and what most people call the 50% rule. If your house is in a flood zone and sits below the required elevation, and the cost of your renovation or repair equals or exceeds 50% of the market value of the building (not the land), the whole house has to be brought up to current flood standards for new construction.
That threshold changes everything. A project that sounds like "just a renovation" can quickly become a question of elevating or rebuilding the entire house. Some towns also count improvements over several years, or set a lower threshold, so it's worth asking your building department how they apply it.
What "compliant" means today
Connecticut has one statewide building code. Projects with permit applications filed since October 1, 2022 fall under the 2022 Connecticut State Building Code, which is based on the 2021 International Codes.
In plain terms, a compliant coastal house today:
Has its lowest floor (in VE zones, its lowest structural framing) above the base flood elevation, plus extra height called freeboard. Some shoreline towns ask for more than the state minimum.
In VE and Coastal A zones, sits on an open foundation, such as piles or columns, so water and waves can pass underneath instead of pushing against solid walls.
Keeps the space below the flood level limited to parking, storage and access, with mechanical and electrical equipment raised above it.
With that picture in mind, here are the three paths.
Option 1: Renovate
Renovating makes sense when the house is already compliant, sits outside the high-risk flood zone, or when the work you want stays well under the 50% threshold.
The catch is the last case. Plenty of homeowners keep projects small to stay under the line, year after year. That can work, but it can also mean putting real money into a house that still floods and still carries a high insurance premium. Before you design around the threshold, it's worth knowing what you're giving up.
Option 2: Raise the house
Lifting an existing house onto a new, taller foundation is a common answer on the coast, and specialized house-lifting contractors do it well. For some homes, such as a historically significant house or a structure that's in very good shape, it can be the right call.
Faros Design does not offer house raising. That's a deliberate choice, and here's our reasoning.
When you lift a house, you pay for a new foundation, temporary support, reconnected utilities, new stairs and access, and repairs to everything that shifts during the move. At the end, you still own the same old framing, windows, insulation and layout, now higher up. In our experience, the money that goes into lifting an older house often gets close to the cost of a new one, without the benefit of a home designed for where it sits.
So we steer clients toward one of two clear paths: renovate a house that already complies, or rebuild with flood protection designed in from the start.
Option 3: Rebuild with flood protection designed in
Rebuilding lets you design the whole house around the site instead of working around an old structure. The foundation, the floor heights, the stairs, the views, the storage below and the mechanical systems are all planned together from day one. It's also the moment to get the layout you actually want.
This is the work Faros Design is built around. Our approach pairs a prefabricated (modular) structure with a foundation of fiberglass piles, connected by the OzziCap, a pile cap system patented by our firm and named after our founder, Ozzie Suarez. Building the house off-site while the foundation goes in can shorten the time on site, which matters on a tight waterfront lot.
It isn't the only way to build on the coast, and it isn't right for every site. But it's a system we designed, patented and have been building with since 2016.
Three questions to ask before you decide
Where does my house sit? Know your flood zone, your base flood elevation and the height of your current lowest floor.
What would the work cost compared with the building's value? If you're near 50%, you're really choosing between compliance and a much smaller project.
What do you want this house to be in 20 years? A careful renovation, or a home built for the water from the ground up?
Where to start
If you're weighing these options, our Coastal Site Assessment is the simplest first step. For $395, we review your property using public records, flood maps and satellite imagery, and give you a clear picture of what's possible before you commit to design. The fee is credited toward your design-build contract if you move forward with us.
[Book a Coastal Site Assessment →] or reach us at info@farosdesign.com or (203) 301-4188.
This article is general information, not a ruling on any specific property. Flood zones, elevations and local requirements vary, and your town's building official and floodplain manager make the final call.



Comments